TAGQ (That's A Good Question)

The Lost Episode

Ben Johnston & Scott Johnston Episode 15

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 34:16

Have you ever wondered how high school popularity shapes our adult selves? Join us as we recount our awe-inspiring, and sometimes intimidating, interactions with the homecoming king whose charisma and thrill-seeking nature left a lasting impression. Fast forward to college, we had an unexpected encounter that transformed our perspective, revealing mutual respect and an unexpected recognition of our career paths. This episode is a heartfelt exploration of the evolution of our desires for social acceptance and how authenticity and self-acceptance become central themes in adulthood.

And what's a late-night chat without some comfort talk? We dive into amusing yet relatable conversations about Tempur-Pedic mattresses and their cozy allure. As we scroll through Twitter, we stumble upon a viral tweet about marriage equality in Minnesota, sparking reflections on personal connections to political events. From family anecdotes like a boss's near-priesthood turned romantic love story to tackling AI's current role and future in creative writing, we keep it candid and conversational. Reflect with us on how popularity, true belonging, and the quest for acceptance shape our lives.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

High School Popularity

Ben

When you were in high school, did you ever wish you were popular?

Scott

Did you ever wish you were popular? I liked the small bits of popularity I got, yeah, but I realized I wasn't playing at the level of. You know, couldn't quite hang. Yeah. Well, let's see the homecoming king. You know, I met like in kindergarten and his dad, like you know, raised him to be the quarterback. Yeah, yeah, yeah. His dad, like you know, raised him to be the quarterback. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And he invited steve and I over. Like in that kindergarten year. We were like in the same church too, right same sunday school yeah um.

Scott

And so his first thing is like here's gonna show I can climb off up this fence and jump off. I'm like, okay, I hadn't had this experience before the five-year-old homecoming king said this, or his dad no, just the, just the kid. His name is Steve too, okay.

Ben

Steve and Scott, okay.

Scott

And I don't know. I just yeah, I was like inexperienced with the thrill of throwing your body from a height.

Ben

But you tried it.

Scott

I think I did. Yeah, it was just like okay, we're not going to hang, are we?

Ben

Yeah, yeah. So you realized at a very young age that you weren't quite cut out for the popularity contest.

Scott

The homecoming.

Ben

Was that the guy that also turned out to be crazy? I remember you talking about how you was it a. It was a girlfriend you had in high school and at some point you broke up and then she started dating some other guy and then he ended up being like he ended up having some serious mental health struggles later in life. I thought I remember hearing a story about that hmm, might not be about me.

Scott

Hmm, might not be about me Might be my mom's friends or something.

Ben

I just I thought I remember you hearing, hearing you at some point talk about like one of my breakups. Oh, you're trying to, you're trying to console me.

Scott

Something that some somebody else in my life.

Ben

Yeah, I don't know, I probably had just broken up with my first girlfriend or something, and you were like, yeah, I really thought I was gonna marry this person I dated and was she married someone else? And he turned out to be crazy.

Scott

So and then he just kind of shrugged I had a girlfriend who turned out to be lesbian, uh but that's, that sounds like it would be a different story.

Ben

That sounds like a different story. I don't know, maybe I'm misremembering, but different Steve, the homecoming king is entirely unrelated.

Scott

I got to hang with him once. I got to hang with him once.

Ben

Later in life.

Scott

No in college.

Ben

That's later in life.

Scott

Yeah, in the dorm.

Ben

Okay, he went to University of Minnesota too. Yeah, and what was that like?

Scott

He's a cool guy, you know. Had no reason to ever interact with him again, you know he was like. You know it's probably going into sales, you know or something in that.

Ben

He wasn't um. He wasn't climbing up tall things and jumping from them anymore.

Scott

Yeah, he expressed sort of like like like well, you got a cool career, he said to me when you were in college.

Ben

Yeah, you had a me when you were in college yeah, you had a career when you were in college? Well, I was a computer science oh, got it, got it, yeah, no he was going business. Yeah, okay, his dad trained him to be a quarterback and his dad trained him to be a businessman, right, right, something like that yeah, yeah okay I mean, I just have this.

Scott

All I remember is the emotion of, of, just like, oh you're, there's something about me that impresses you. I forget the content.

Ben

He did want to be popular pardon, you cared about, you really cared about what he thought. Even after you graduated, you did say you appreciated the small amount of popularity you got. So yeah, it's we all. We all want to be liked by people that are well liked yeah yeah, yeah, I feel like I would have a similar answer to the question, but sorry, I interrupted.

Scott

You were saying that you, you were surprised that he, he, uh, he liked what you had yeah, because they didn't, you know, hadn't been in this system of um, it might be real, right, cool I took the picture. I didn't tell you, sorry system hey, yeah, I don't know, interesting, I always thought he was kind of a nice guy, I mean in kindergarten and you know, I mean in kindergarten and you know Onward. Yeah, he was never a jerk. Never a jerk which is like pretty good.

Ben

That's the thing about like popularity. It's like people are popular for for reasons, and a lot of the time they're like they're the people that are really popular are the ones that are both really cool and just really stand up people but my mind is in protest of that idea.

Scott

I want to deconstruct who cares about being popular. You know Well you do.

Ben

You liked it, true? Sorry, I just thought.

Scott

I have never thought of popularity outside of high school got it, got it, got it, got it.

Ben

Yeah, nor should we. Yes, yes, yes, yes. Um, I I just came into the, the recording, thinking my brother with the neighbors, I don't know no I don't want to. I don't want to have.

Scott

You don't want to be popular with the neighbors, and it's just oh, I'm going to be what I am, and if that impacts my popularity, then yeah, okay, yeah, yeah, oh I just I came into the reggae band on the street I mean, yeah, it happened.

Ben

This podcast is called. That's a Good Question. I'm like, okay, well, I need to ask the question. It's a good way to open things up. You know, when you first, when you start a podcast on your phone, it's like the first sound you hear is very important.

Ben

We should end the introduction by introducing ourselves, and then we can take a break yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly yeah, but, um, I think I said a few things in there that I don't actually mean I. This all makes it sound like I think about popularity a lot more than I do, but me, of all people, I uh I'm very much like you dad, and that it's uh not something I think about that often. Um, or maybe I do, oh God.

Scott

Well, maybe I do too, but um you learn to? Yes, we all do. I'm at this cabin in November and no one's.

Ben

At this cabin, At this cabin. Get this in your head. People Get this image in your head.

Scott

No one's around. Is it a cabin? Actually, the neighbors are here.

Ben

In November.

Scott

The neighbors are here, they came to do their leaves too. My sister told me that I had to do their leaves too. My sister told me that I had to do the leaves.

Ben

The leaves. You had to do the leaves.

Scott

We have more than one question.

Ben

Don't forget to do the leaves. Scott, when are we? What does it mean to do the leaves?

Scott

We're going to have the introductions at the end of the hour.

Scott

Is that how this works?

Ben

Hi, my name is Ben and I'm here with my dad, who's in a cabin in the woods, in November. I'm in a cabin in the woods in November. Welcome to the podcast, everyone. Hi how are you doing? I'm good. I'm not drinking caffeine. I haven't been drinking caffeine for about the last week and a half just under two weeks. Wow, I haven't been sleeping that well for the last couple of years of my life and I'm pulling out the last stop. See what happens um.

Ben

I slept the most hours of my life last night really, I slept the most hours last night of like probably the last year of my life, but the the most hours of your entire life. Last night, how long did you sleep? What do you attribute this to?

Scott

This is like winter to me. I don't know Everyone's gone. I didn't even want to go out last night. It's. Saturday night and you didn't.

Ben

You didn't even feel like partying no yeah, yeah what time do you? Go to bed. What time do you wake up?

Scott

I'm to sleep in that really hard temper pedic that we bought oh, so when you and mom share, yep yeah because, it's not on the bandwagon and it's really hard and it especially when it cold. It gets harder when it's colder. Yeah, You're sitting on this thing that feels like a soft stone that keeps sinking beneath you.

Ben

Soft stone Approaching uncomfortability. That's Tempur-Pedic Brought to rising by tempur-pedic. Everyone like sleeping on a soft stone and it works. It works well. You said you slept more hours last night than you have in your entire life yeah um. So there must be something to be said about sleeping on soft stones yeah, maybe get them as an advertiser whichever, yeah, we could do that, we could do that. Could, do that, the Purple Boys could be our arch nemeses. Ever seen the Purple Boys?

Scott

No, they make mattresses.

Ben

No, they, it's uh, tim and eric. Um, the comedians they have, uh, they used to have commercial for I I can't remember if the company is is purple, if they're but they they did commercials for and they were just super unhinged, but I think it worked. It got me thinking differently about my mattress. What time did you go to bed?

Scott

Oh, this is a question. Oh, about what time did I go to bed? Nine, I suppose, no eight. It gets dark so early here.

Ben

Yeah, yeah, I think we're at a similar latitude. It's like 445. It's pretty dark here, yeah Right, what time did you wake up?

Scott

Nine something. Wow For the last time.

Ben

I mean, you know, did you get up at all in the middle of the night? Sure.

Scott

I get up on twitter until I go back back.

Ben

I longer last night than I have in my entire life and I woke up in the middle of the night to check Twitter. Wow.

Scott

It's, like, you know, kind of being an amateur journalist. I know I'm going to pay you.

Ben

Crawling through Twitter makes you an amateur journalist.

Scott

Well, it certainly makes me an amateur journalist.

Ben

I think with that kind of power comes much more responsibility than pretty much anyone who uses Twitter deserves. Oh Sorry, that's not true, I'm not asking for that. It's like asking to like have relevant comedy you know, it's just like no I'm gonna say what's funny to me um, I see, I see, so you share on twitter. You Twitter, you're not just a passive scroller. No, I got it.

Scott

You share your character-age. A lot of things with no response from anybody.

Ben

Yeah, just like.

Scott

You could look if you wanted.

Ben

Yeah, I don't. I don't have the desire to sign up for that website, especially nowadays.

Scott

But if I mailed you a list of my tweets, you'd look at them.

Ben

Yeah, yeah, I would Definitely so they're highly consumables, highly consumable.

Scott

Yeah, I read back on my tweet history and I go, oh, that's smart, that's smart, oh cool. It's like all good material and I should just before I have to pay for it, I should go download it.

Ben

How often do you go viral? Once.

Scott

Oh, oh yeah, what was it?

Ben

once. Oh yeah, what was it?

Scott

talking about visiting my mom just before marriage equality got passed in Minnesota and now seeing her boss like on TV that day and him going against it as a Democrat, which was surprising and uh-huh yeah, so you just shared, kind of, you just shared a recollection of that no, it was like a day the day after it passed in Minnesota oh good it was like, like, like, like. Like you know, it was like yeah, I mean something about her connection to the Capitol and everything was in the tweet.

Ben

Yeah right.

Scott

Yeah, okay, well, that is a good story. That is like a.

Ben

Tell the story in a few words.

Scott

Well, yeah, okay, okay, I got a story for after the podcast. I'll tell you oh, okay, okay, okay, I got a story for after the podcast.

Ben

I'll tell you oh man, you got to edit, you know. You're really depriving the people here, man. Yeah, they're at the edge of their seats waiting to hear yeah, yeah, so your mom, so you're saying her boss you're. So how old would grandma mj be? Right now she would be 30 more than me 30 more than me. That's like 94.

Scott

She'd be 94.

Ben

She was alive, She'd be 94. So you're saying when did marriage equality pass in Minnesota?

Scott

I think 2016, but I might be off one way or the other.

Ben

Her boss? Is he still working for the state?

Scott

He was a senator.

Ben

Yeah, okay.

Scott

He kept on being a senator Okay.

Ben

So he retired from his gig.

Scott

Yeah.

Ben

The gig in which he was grandma's boss. Yeah, and he continued to be a senator. Okay, got it, got it, got it. So just an old white dude as a Democrat coming to say grumpy and he was a priest candidate. Priest candidate.

Scott

Yeah, he had signed up to become a Catholic priest. Okay. And he bailed because he fell in love.

Ben

Uh-huh, yeah, yeah, with someone his own age.

Scott

With a female too. But I mean, he had this history of, you know, thinking out of the box.

Ben

I almost became a Catholic priest. I think outside the box.

Scott

I just expected more from him, yeah.

Ben

Yeah, yeah, okay, yeah. Well, sometimes you go.

Scott

I think, I think, I think, yeah, he was, he was, he was a, he was a good guy, Um, um with yeah, not everyone's clear of the mindset of the.

Ben

Catholic church.

Scott

Catholic church oh, got it, got it, got it, yeah. Catholic church yeah, a whole bunch of things to uh the way jesus wanted us to be yeah, sorry, you said the catholic church.

Ben

What about the way? Way Jesus wanted us to be?

Scott

I'm kind of like I want you know raw Jesus. You know not raw Jesus, not yet yeah. Raw, not all that stuff added on, all right.

Ben

What a choice of words. God wants raw Jesus. I know what you mean. I know what you mean Better than you and I mean, yes, yeah, I mean that's kind of. Original.

Scott

Original.

Ben

Yeah Right, I mean, yeah, it's the thing about institutions Comes great power comes great responsibility. You haven't done a very good job. I don't think that the thought of that man impacted the Roman. Empire. You do think the thought of that man impacted the Roman Empire.

Scott

I think the EU would be what it is without the thought of that man impacting the Roman Empire. Wow, this is really deep what.

Ben

Wait, you do think the EU would have been the same with or without I think the thought of Jesus, not I mean.

Scott

The Roman Empire conquered the Christians right.

Ben

Yeah, right, well, at the first, when they first started bubbling up. Yeah.

Scott

Uh-huh. Then they melded yeah, it was like the power structure didn't go away. Have you been to the Vatican power?

Ben

well, that's that's. The thing is that it's. Jesus was very, very critical of the powers that be, and then the powers that be couldn't, couldn't, defeat him. So and his ideas? So they became him and his ideas. So they became him and his ideas and then used it to enrich and you know, we have what we have now because of it. So what do you mean? This is deep. This is just a way of things. This is this, this is it's. It's just the way of things. Someone with a lot of spirit comes through and inspires everybody, culture is completely changed, and then the institutions commandeer it and then it becomes rigid and constricting and actually really, really harmful and totally out of sync with what the original intention was. Yeah, wow, I think it's, yeah's, wow, yeah, it's a pattern. That just happened.

Scott

Can I put all that on a bumper sticker?

Ben

uh, yeah, yeah, yeah, it'd be. Uh, you know, I got 11 by 17 bumper sticker. Go for it. No other way to narrow it down, I don't know.

Scott

Just get a jesus fish with legs oh, I've been using chat gpt and lately we've been working together can I put that on a bumper sticker?

Ben

I've been using chat GPT. Is it GPT or BT?

Scott

P. P as in Peter, p as in Peter.

Ben

Okay.

Scott

Anyway yeah. And I'm working on a historical novel of a chance meeting.

Ben

Sorry, okay, I need to put that on a bumper sticker. I've been using chat GBT. Put it on the other side. I'm working on a historical novel. Okay, yeah, okay, I'm with you. Sure, you're really. Wow. Talk about chop wood, carry water.

Ben

Just let the computer do it no, it helps a lot, is like would there ever been a chance that you know who dread scott is uh, who's got red scott, dread scott yeah I only know the name from the dread scott decision and learning about it in high school and just knowing that that exists but having no idea what it was a slave who was brought to Minnesota okay.

Scott

I had a case, you know, because of that yeah and so like did Dred Scott ever meet Henry Sibley and or little crow? Or maybe they all met in the 18th?

Ben

Uh-huh.

Scott

No one knows. They didn't. They were all at the same place, same time.

Ben

Right, uh-huh. So you're you. You are harnessing the powers of artificial intelligence to get to the bottom of it, and and I'm adding intelligence to get to the bottom of it.

Scott

And and I'm adding Lincoln and Darwin to the story Lincoln is an obvious connection, right?

Ben

Right, right. Yeah, you know, never meet those four slash five characters.

Scott

No, he was like in South Americaica, but in the pacific. You know, yeah, right during these years, english man with the button nose in the pacific um, lincoln was actually fighting the blackhawk during these years, like in in Wisconsin, or you know.

Ben

Like actually fighting, like on the ground.

Scott

Putting together a military force and going out and see if they could find a fight, and they didn't, which is kind of the same thing Sibley did.

Ben

Sibley, is he the one that the is your high school named after him?

Scott

Yeah, he rounded the largest mass, the people for the largest mass execution as a general of the US Army.

Ben

Yeah, why do you want to know if some of these colonists and imperialists hung out with Dred Scott?

Scott

and Little Crow yeah no only. Oh okay, who else who?

Ben

are you adding? I'm? I'm sorry, I'm not trying to add anyone. I'm wondering like why? So dred scott shows up in minnesota, henry sibley is doing his colonist thing and abraham lincoln's in wisconsin doing his colonist thing, and and abraham lincoln's in wisconsin doing his colonist thing and um are you trying to write a novel?

Scott

no, it's interesting. There's the. There's the person who came there, uh, on their own will. There's the person who came there not on their own will uh-huh yeah yeah, the person who was there, you know, yeah, right yeah, you know okay, each is history makers of the time. Yeah.

Ben

Yeah, how, how long does?

Scott

interact as humans would be interesting in a story.

Ben

Yeah, it definitely would. So kind of like historical fiction is what you're putting together.

Scott

Yeah, yeah, so kind of like historical fiction is what you're putting together. Yeah, yeah, okay, imagining things that are possible but not documented.

Ben

Right, right, yep, yep, yep.

Scott

I mean somebody met. I mean simply, after his European wife died, married a native.

Ben

Yeah.

Scott

Brain. Figure it out in a moment. I don't know the name Top of my tip of my tongue. Figure it out in a moment. I don't know the name Top of my tip of my tongue.

Ben

Well, when the AI gets that story together.

Scott

Well, I wouldn't write it without confirming the things it says, because it makes up stuff.

Ben

Oh my god.

Scott

It does.

Ben

You know that, don't you? I encourage you to think of what your end goal is for letting this piece of computing let loose on this topic.

Scott

No, it's really just like a convenient thing to. It's like talking to a friend who knows a lot but doesn't know everything you know okay and just fills in the blanks with whatever the fuck you think. So yeah, okay that's what it is very constructive wow, okay, so long as you know ask it to like lay out a whole thing, and it'll give you, like chapter by chapter, what you should.

Ben

Oh yeah, oh yeah. Oh. I know, but it can't make people laugh very easily. We've talked about that before. It's not good at making people laugh. No. No.

Scott

No no. Elaborate. Yeah, right, yeah, it might get better, who knows.

Ben

We'll see. I hope it does not get better, but it probably will. Probably will. All right, we got a minute and 15 seconds.

Scott

What was the original question? Oh, what do you feel about being popular?

Ben

Did you ever want to be popular in high school? That was the question, and I mean, I think, for a lot of us, me included to impress women. Yes, yes, sorry, yeah, sure, okay. I mean, that's always, it's always an element of the whole popularity thing, but it does not tell the whole story. We just want belonging. We just want belonging, and I think at some point in our lives we realize that the popularity contest isn't actually the route towards true belonging.

Scott

I didn't really want to agree. Though I didn't really want to agree, I was like the perfect candidate to take off to the city.

Ben

You know To be homecoming king, you were the perfect candidate to take off to the city. You know To be homecoming king, you were the perfect candidate.

Scott

No, no, You're first folks, no, no no, you're ending on Bye.

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Judge John Hodgman Artwork

Judge John Hodgman

John Hodgman and Maximum Fun
Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend Artwork

Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend

Team Coco & Earwolf
E Pluribus Motto Artwork

E Pluribus Motto

John Hodgman and Janet Varney
I, Podius Artwork

I, Podius

Maximum Fun
Jordan, Jesse, GO! Artwork

Jordan, Jesse, GO!

MaximumFun.org
Monday Morning Podcast Artwork

Monday Morning Podcast

All Things Comedy
The Lonely Island and Seth Meyers Podcast Artwork

The Lonely Island and Seth Meyers Podcast

The Lonely Island & Seth Meyers